Jan 26, 2012 why we have a responsibility to protect syria. Libya, the responsibility to protect and the future of humanitarian intervention a. The concept of the responsibility to protect rtop has gone through significant developments in recent years, and its use in the latest crisis in libya appears to follow a new approach of intervention in the international community. The eus responsibility to protect in the libyan crisis. Libya and the future of the responsibility to protect 3 by the popularization of the concepts of human security and civilian protection, even though each organization has adopted a somewhat different reading of these concepts. Responsibility to protect remains worthy, yet elusive. For 350 years since westphalia, sovereignty functioned as institutionalised indifference. The responsibility to protect in malcolm d evans ed, international law oxford university press, 3rd ed, 2010. Although the intervention and resolutions on libya can be seen as a triumph for the responsibility to protect doctrine, the actors involved still vary widely in their commitment to the doctrine, which is clearly seen in the way the libyan nofly zone was prepared. This article explores the responsibility to protect rtop in the post libya era to determine whether it is now an accepted norm of international law. Debating the responsibility to protect in libya, syria.
Responsibility to protect and its applicability in libya. The bricibsa countries brazil, russia, india, china, and south africa. The emerging principle of the responsibility to protect r2p challenges chinas traditional emphasis on nonintervention in the domestic affairs of other states and nonuse of force. Syria another drawback for r2p an analysis of r2ps. Apr 06, 2012 the responsibility to protect has been the subject of considerable debate in recent weeks, particularly as the international community continues to pursue an end to the violent crisis in syria, and the transition in postgaddafi libya moves forward with both uncertainty and concern. Protection of civilians has remained problematic either when it occurs. Aus responsibility to protect in the libyan crisis 2011. This intervention was legitimized by invoking r2p responsibility to protect and since then, r2p has been a reoccurring subject within the unsc. Emerging powers and the responsibility to protect after libya ramesh thakur summary unauthorized intervention in libya in 2011 was a textbook illustration of r2p principles. Libya is but one of many recent and ongoing examples where international responses to major humanitarian emergencies have been framed by a focus on the victims. The genesis of the doctrinetheory of the responsibility to protect r2prtop was supposed to resolve some of the problems associated with humanitarian intervention as an additional exception to the nonuse of force in international law. The responsibility to protect r2p doctrine, after its first ever implementation in libya, has halted in syria.
Libya and the responsibility to protect between opportunistic humanitarianism and value free pragmatism the application of the responsibility to protect r2p norm to libya in 2011 was successful but controversial. The applicability of the responsibility to protect or r2p principle to the current situation in libya is undeniable. The use of force to protect civilians and humanitarian action. In recent years, the doctrine of responsibility to protect had been steadily gaining traction, particularly among scholars and commentators. The main topic of my thesis is responsibility to protect from libya to syria. The security councils press statement on libya yesterday included a phrase that ought to pique some interest. Implementing the responsibility to protect, outlining three principles, or pillars, of r2p. This intervention was legitimized by invoking r2p responsibility to protect and since then, r2p has. Article information, pdf download for responding to failure. Report of the international commission on intervention and state sovereignty 2001 international development research centre 7. On march 26, 2015, a coalition of gulf states led by saudi arabia launched a military intervention into yemens ongoing civil war.
First, we recapitulate the emergence of r2p and the. Currently the united nations includes 193 member states. But the operation and aftermath also prove the need for legitimacy criteria to guide decisions on authorizing and overseeing international military intervention. Mission accomplished would mean the libyan people free to control. Emerging powers and the responsibility to protect after libya. Rhetoric, reality and the future of humanitarian intervention palgrave macmillan, 2012 international law, security and ethics coeditor, routledge, 2011 humanitarian intervention. Oct 12, 2011 critics of the responsibility to protect r2p and interventionism in general have long accused international humanitarian action of being a form of imperialism cloaked in humanitarianism. This article will trace the roots of responsibility to protect rtop in international law and international ethics. Apr 06, 2015 responsibility to protect r2p panacea or trojan horse for intervention.
They called upon the libyan authorities to act with restraint, to respect human rights and international. Libya, the responsibility to protect and the future of. Postlibya opposition to the responsibility to protect. Protection situation overview, januaryfebruary 2018. The new politics of protection cte divoire, libya and the. Mar 01, 2011 libya and the responsibility to protect. This intervention was legitimized by invoking r2p responsibility to. This thesis examines the 2011 intervention in libya, focusing on the distinct influences of the national, regional and international levels of governance on the decisionmaking process. Why we have a responsibility to protect syria the atlantic. It examines the r2p legal framework in coordination with events on the ground in libya during the early part of 2011 in order to thoroughly explain that r2p was correctly invoked by the united nations security council in order to uphold international law. Pdf download for cosmopolitanism, responsibility to protect and the. Arrangements in implementing the responsibility protect in 2011. The members of the security council called on the government of libya to meet its responsibility to protect its population. From this it may be possible to have a better understanding of how and when the responsibility to protect triggers the responsibility to react and to identify a framework, under the rtop principle, in which.
Libya and the responsibility to protect united states. Ending mass atrocity crimes once and for all brookings. The responsibility to protect had been implemented selectively in the past, she said, noting that international law and international human rights law should be respected in all. After resolution 1973, however, the doctrine of responsibility to protect lost substantial support from the international community. The purpose of this research is to explore the moral, legal and practical implications of the. Responsibility to protect to justify libya intervention steven groves this. May 02, 2015 the genesis of the doctrinetheory of the responsibility to protect r2prtop was supposed to resolve some of the problems associated with humanitarian intervention as an additional exception to the nonuse of force in international law. Apart from the changing referent object, human security promotes different means to protect security. The responsibility to protect rtop played an important role in shaping the worlds response to actual and threatened atrocities in libya. I was an early supporter of military intervention in libya.
The responsibility to protect after libya and syria the. Responsibility to protect r2p, which was at the basis of the intervention in libya. During its first decade in existence, the responsibility to protect r2p. The responsibility to protect in syria and beyond after the 1994 genocide in rwanda, world leaders vowed that such mass atrocities could never be allowed to happen again. The responsibility to protect rests on three pillars. Consensus on the use of force against libya was enabled by several excep. To prevent a freewheeling interpretation of mandates in future cases, an. The libyan intervention, triumph and downfall of the. It is, on the other hand, deeply familiar to international ethics, a widening of the circumstances that allow for overriding nonintervention. In response to muammar elqaddafis continued assaults on civilians in libya, the united nations. The coalition justified its entry into the conflict principally by reference to its responsibility to protect the people and the legitimate government of yemen.
Oct 07, 2011 supporters of the idea of a responsibility to protect have to be troubled that brazil, india, and south africa all abstained on the syria vote even though it had been watered down almost to. First and foremost, r2p reflects the negative duty for states to refrain from committing atrocities against its own people, a responsibility the regime of col. The libyan crisis has brought focus to the critical and complex issue of the responsibility to protect populations from genocide, war crimes, crimes against humanity, and ethnic cleansing. May 2011 impact of action in libya on the responsibility to. United nations security council resolution 1973 and the. The responsibility to protect and international law. Libya and the future of the responsibility to protect peace palace. Implementing the responsibility to protect 2009 based on the outcome document of the 2005 world summit, a 2009 report by the secretary general outlined a strategy around three pillars of the. An introduction palgrave macmillan, 2010 kosovo, intervention and statebuilding editor, routledge, 2010. Libya and the future of the responsibility to protect. The concerns over the use of force based on resolution 1973 in libya. Responsibility to protect r2p panacea or trojan horse for intervention. May 29, 20 libya, the responsibility to protect and the future of humanitarian intervention a.
Cosmopolitanism, responsibility to protect and the libya. For recent booklength treatments of the responsibility to protect, see also gareth evans, the responsibility to protect. In this article the libyan and syrian cases are analysed with a view to. Responsibility to protect populations from genocide, war crimes. The paper shows that important ambivalences in the concept of r2p. The responsibility to protect has had a number of opportunities to continue to evolve and assert itself in an international legal context throughout the ensuing years since the kosovo intervention. Supporters of the idea of a responsibility to protect have to be troubled that brazil, india, and south africa all abstained on the syria vote even though it had been watered down almost to. Libya and the responsibility to protect r2p suggests that states have a responsibility to take diplomatic, humanitarian and, yes, military action to protect populations the world over. Mar 30, 2011 but whilst the response to libya marks a number of significant milestones, it is important to stress that the responsibility to protect rtop does not begin and end with libya. Murray springer, may 29, 20 political science 240 pages. Revisiting responsibility to protect after libya and syria. Libya multilevel governance responsibility to protect.
Critics of the responsibility to protect r2p and interventionism in general have long accused international humanitarian action of being a form of imperialism cloaked in humanitarianism. Apart from the changing referent object, human security promotes different means to. How ought christians think of policy in protecting the vulnerable. Libya and the responsibility to protect libya reliefweb. Opinion libya and the responsibility to protect the new. Rtop is in tension with established charter law on the use of force, but it may be beginning to change the law. The doctrine of responsibility to protect r2p holds that when a sovereign state fails to prevent atrocities, foreign governments may intervene to stop them. Responsibility to protect to justify libya intervention steven groves this paper, in its entirety, can be found at. I will particularly apply r2p to the recent case of libya and the current situation in syria. Looking for the effective measures to prevent systematic violations of human rights and core crimes of international law, the international commission on intervention and state sovereignty in december 2001 released the report responsibility to protect. The international system is characterized by increased instability, the sharpening of deadly conflicts, mass atrocities and the emergence of transnational extremists armed groups such as the islamic state of iraq and syria isis. Libya and the responsibility to protect comment magazine.
Libya, the responsibility to protect and the future of humanitarian intervention. Bellamy t he responsibility to protect rtop played an important role in shaping the worlds response to actual and threatened atrocities in libya. Responsibility while protecting rwp and the intervention in. The president stated that when our interests and values are at no. The responsibility to protect has been the subject of considerable debate in recent weeks, particularly as the international community continues to pursue an end to the violent crisis in syria, and the transition in postgaddafi libya moves forward with both uncertainty and concern. Protect r2p and the responsibility while protecting rwp. Engaging emerging powers 20 36 the washington quartely 64. Libya, the responsibility to protect and the future of humanitarian intervention hehir, a. Concept and implementation, opportunity and misuse the r2p attempt failed in libya dr.
1202 325 192 1048 1511 898 1231 632 1237 922 171 118 1587 775 1451 1502 1058 1095 1562 889 870 1407 707 1221 1474 426 1001 1034 43 1579 1532 539 655 420 1281 1169 230 834 1120 159 323 982 998 916 550 1021 748